Commonly when dates are provided, they are considering having a day of your week that do not match thereupon go out because it when you look at the genuine records. One particular analogy occurs in Harry Potter as well as the Prisoner away from Azkaban whenever Sybill Trelawney identifies 16 October as the Tuesday, regardless of if sixteen October 1993 is actually a monday.
You will be able, but not impractical, you to Fudge could be referring to a more faraway predecessor, as the Thatcher got work environment just before Fudge allegedly turned Minister having Wonders
There are also contradictions inside the books in this region. Such, into the Harry Potter as well as the Cup of Fire, each other step one September and you can 2 September are supplied because Mondays and you can, for the Harry Potter in addition to Prisoner away from Azkaban, Buckbeak’s demo is determined into 20 April, but cautious parsing of one’s text reveals that it may have taken place no after than March.
Including, in the Harry Potter plus the Goblet of Fire people say that the Champions have been chose towards Tuesday 30 October, however, 30 Oct try a friday when you look at the 1994. Yet not, it had been later on stated that 22 November was a tuesday, it was at 1994.
In the a bankruptcy proceeding out-of Quidditch From the Ages, they claim your very first Quidditch Globe Cup happened inside the 1473. If for example the championship try held most of the several years, that it conflicts into the statement during the Cup out-of Fire that 1994 World Cup try the newest 422nd. When the Quidditch Through the Years is great, the latest 422nd Quidditch Community Mug manage in fact belong the season 3161, however if Goblet from Flames is right, the original Industry Cup was kept in 306.
Historic difficulties
While the show, depending on the timeline based on new Chamber regarding Treasures source, is determined regarding the 1990s, new show tend to looks as though it is place in the latest late nineties to middle-2000s, approximately concurrent into the publication of one’s guides. Inside Harry Potter together with 1 / 2 of-Bloodstream Prince, Cornelius Fudge uses a masculine pronoun to mention towards “predecessor” of one’s Prime Minister of one’s British. According to above timeline, this would take place in the summer months away from 1996, if Finest Minister was John Big, whoever quick predecessor are a female (‘s the reason first meeting with Fudge, the ebook says brand new election, however, Major was not initially select and just took more after Thatcher resigned.
(In the event one could consider a situation where Fudge was delegated because of the Minister to possess Magic to meet up with on the Primary Minister while he, Fudge, was in a smaller place of work.) On top of that, the brand new identity and you can history of the top Minister depicted generally seems to a lot more directly fits that of Tony Blair than regarding John Big. A post throughout the Each day Send notes one to Rowling was close into after that-Chancellor of your own Exchequer Gordon Brownish (tend to regarded examine the site as an opponent in order to Blair’s management of Labor Cluster, who been successful your and turned into Finest Minister), and this she might have been trying to reveal Blair’s bad top. Should your courses had been invest connect which have book day regarding Philosopher’s Stone, then it knowledge manage take place in 2002 (immediately after Blair became Perfect Minister).
The same state concerns Nicolas Flamel, who was simply stated to be 665 in the course of this new basic book, but Nicolas Flamel try a bona fide historic figure and you can wouldn’t have reached one many years up to 1996, in the big date the original book is actually published. New rebuttal for this is the fact that big date the fresh “real” Nicolas Flamel was born cannot communicate with brand new Nicolas Flamel out of Harry Potter.
Another situation is obtainable regarding Rubeus Hagrid’s tenure because Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It is intended in the collection one to Hagrid got you to definitely reputation inside a couple of years out-of their expulsion away from college or university inside 1942. However in you to scene from Harry Potter as well as the Cup from Flame, Molly Weasley reminisces regarding Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper appear to convergence having Molly’s age in school, it appears unrealistic one to she remembers an earlier gamekeeper. not, it’s possible that Hagrid failed to feel a great gamekeeper instantly immediately following being expelled, but alternatively been as the Ogg’s assistant. It is possible due to the fact when Harry thinks he tend to feel expelled to own traveling with the broomstick instead of permission within his first year, the guy magic in the event the he’d be allowed to remain on since Hagrid’s assistant.